The Hidden Cost of Always Being Nice

Sarah was known as the office superhero—the one who'd drop everything to help with last-minute presentations, cover for absent colleagues, and stay late without complaint. Her calendar was a maze of "quick favors" and "small requests," while her own projects gathered dust. One Friday, as she prepared to cancel another dinner with her family to handle a colleague's emergency, her seven-year-old daughter's words stopped her cold: "Mom, why do you help everyone except us?" That moment shattered her perception of being helpful—she wasn't being kind, she was avoiding conflict at the cost of what mattered most. Today, Sarah still helps others, but on her terms. Her most powerful word isn't "yes" anymore—it's "let me think about it."

We all struggle between fitting in and being true to ourselves. While acceptance is a basic human need, compromising our integrity often leads to burnout. How do we balance authenticity and social connection?

🚘 Why Are We Driven to Please Others?

Science shows that people-pleasing often comes from a deep need for social approval and fear of rejection, which can be linked to early childhood experiences. If someone grew up in an environment where love or acceptance felt conditional—based on being helpful, agreeable, or avoiding conflict—they may develop people-pleasing as a survival strategy. Psychologists also connect it to high empathy, low self-esteem, and even overactive stress responses, where saying "no" feels like a threat. Over time, this behavior gets reinforced because it leads to short-term rewards, like praise or avoiding disappointment, even though it can lead to burnout and resentment in the long run. Additionally, societal and workplace expectations can reinforce this behavior, making it even harder to break the cycle. The challenge is finding the balance between building strong relationships and honoring our personal integrity.

🚨 It's a Trap!

Always saying yes might seem like the path to success and acceptance, but it's often a road to self-sabotage. When we consistently prioritize others' needs over our own, we don't just drain our energy—we erode our credibility. Ironically, constant agreement makes us appear less trustworthy and reliable, not more. The real cost shows up in burned bridges, missed opportunities, and compromised values. Our careers stagnate because we're too busy fighting other people's fires to build our own path. Meanwhile, the resentment builds silently, poisoning relationships and creating a cycle of passive-aggressive behavior that undermines the very connections we're trying to preserve. The truth is, setting boundaries isn't just about saying no—it's about saying yes to our own growth, authenticity, and long-term success.

‼️ Why Is It Important for Democratic Leaders?

To lead democratically, you must often confront this question: Will you do what you know is right, or what you think others want you to do? While you need to balance diverse perspectives and make tough decisions, you must stand by your values—even when faced with disagreement. The trap of populism lies in always saying what people want to hear (to please them), regardless of your true beliefs, whether to avoid difficult conversations, feel liked, or gain support. This leads down a dark path—not only are you betraying your values, but you'll never be able to satisfy everyone. To avoid disappointing people, you might resort to lying or scapegoating—blaming others for your inability to deliver on promises. This creates a vicious cycle of lies that corrupts your character and builds a system designed to sustain those lies. Eventually, loyalty becomes more important than competence. At the end of this path, everyone loses.

The opposite of people pleasing is listening to people (curiosity), honesty, transparency, integrity, courage, and being authentic. You have to know who you are and what you stand for.

❓️ What Can You Do?

Here are practical steps to uncover and overcome people-pleasing:

1️⃣ Pause Before Saying Yes

🔹️ People-pleasers tend to agree automatically out of habit. Break this cycle by pausing before answering any request.

🔹️ New habit: always ask for additional time to respond, no matter how much you want to say YES right away.

🔹️ Practice: Say, "Let me think about it and get back to you." This gives you time to decide based on your priorities, not guilt or pressure.

2️⃣ Set Small, Clear Boundaries

🔹️ Start with low-stakes situations where saying no feels less risky.

🔹️ New mindset: "My worth isn't based on making others happy."

🔹️ Practice: Use short, firm, and kind responses, like:

• I can't take that on right now.

• I appreciate the invite, but I'll have to pass.

• I'd love to help, but I don't have the bandwidth.

3️⃣ Get Comfortable with Discomfort

🔹️ The fear of disappointing others is what keeps people-pleasing going. Learn to sit with that discomfort without giving in.

🔹️ New mindset: "It's okay if they're disappointed. Their feelings are not my responsibility."

4️⃣ Build Self-Worth Beyond External Approval

🔹️ This is a long-term strategy

🔹️ Practice: Define who you are - write down on paper or computer who you are, including your values, beliefs, characteristics, and habits you want to honor in your life.

🔹️ Action step: List as many as you want, but ultimately select your top 10 most important ones and highlight them in bold

🔹️ Daily practice: Read this every day before you start your work

Your worth isn't measured by the number of times you say yes—it's defined by staying true to your values, even when it means saying no. Like a compass pointing north, your integrity should guide your decisions, not the fear of disappointment or the craving for approval.

➕Additional Resources

Here are other takes on the subject of people-pleasing that I found interesting:

📚 Dr. Ilene S. Cohen's When It's Never About You: The People-Pleaser's Guide to Reclaiming Your Health, Happiness, and Personal Freedom offers insights into overcoming people-pleasing behaviors to enhance personal well-being.

🎬 In her TEDx talk, "Why People Pleasing is Hurting You" Salma Hindy discusses the detrimental effects of people-pleasing and emphasizes the importance of setting boundaries.

📰 The article "The Courage to be Disliked: Break free from people-pleasing" provides strategies to overcome the habit of people-pleasing and emphasizes the importance of self-acceptance.

📚 Sunita Sah's book, Defy: The Power of No in a World that Demands Yes, explores the psychology behind the difficulty of saying no and offers guidance on asserting oneself, as highlighted in a recent article.

🤝 Know Someone Who Could Benefit from This?

You can make a difference today by sharing insights about people-pleasing & leadership with a friend or colleague who could benefit from them. Forward this newsletter to one person whose personal growth you want to support. They can subscribe here: https://pulseofchange.org/

🎁 Free Workshop: Navigating Organizational Culture and Politics

Success requires more than just skills - it's about understanding workplace dynamics. Learn to navigate organizational culture and politics effectively while staying true to your values in our free one-hour workshop.

📅 February 24th

⏰ 12–1 PM ET (6-7pm CET)

📍 Zoom

Seeking impartial news? Meet 1440.

Every day, 3.5 million readers turn to 1440 for their factual news. We sift through 100+ sources to bring you a complete summary of politics, global events, business, and culture, all in a brief 5-minute email. Enjoy an impartial news experience.

Join for free today!